A new study by Avalere Health identified the key challenges facing health insurance exchanges created by the Affordable Care Act (ACA) and considers a range of potential policy options that could be combined to improve the sustainability of the market into the future.
A new study by Avalere Health identified the key challenges facing health insurance exchanges created by the Affordable Care Act (ACA) and considers a range of potential policy options that could be combined to improve the sustainability of the market into the future.
For example, the new analysis found that individuals who enroll in exchange coverage through special enrollment periods (SEPs) in fact have higher costs and lower risk scores than open enrollment period (OEP) consumers. Specifically, the SEP enrollees in 2015 had 5% higher per-member, per-month (PMPM) costs than the OEP enrollees. Their risk scores were also 20% lower on average.
“Consumers enrolling through special enrollment periods have higher healthcare spending than those picking a plan during open enrollment, and they are staying in the program for shorter periods of time,” said Dan Mendelson, president of Avalere. “This is one of many technical problems that is presently destabilizing this program, and should be fixed by the administration and the Congress to ensure continuity for patients.”
Challenges Facing the Exchange Market
Since their inception in 2014, exchanges have enrolled millions of consumers in health insurance. While it is a major accomplishment considering one-third of these enrollees didn't even have insurance before, some challenges still remained.
Enrollment was lower than projected: Even though millions of Americans enrolled in the exchanges, the numbers were still short of projections. The Congressional Budget Office had projected 22 million enrollees by 2016. However, based on the current trends, enrollment by the end of 2016 is expected to be just over 10 million.
Penalties may be less effective: The ACA had established an individual mandate penalty for individuals who forgo purchasing insurance. However, the penalty was too low to effectively attract enrollment. For middle-income, healthy individuals, paying the penalty was easier than opting for insurance.
Adverse selection of exchange population: The population that has enrolled in the exchange programs in fact did not represent the population eligible to enroll. The enrollees were disproportionately older, lower-income, and in poorer health than the potential population.
Overall, the lower-than-expected enrollment, a costlier and less stable enrollee population, and inadequate risk mitigation programs are posing a threat to the stability and sustainability of the market.
Policy Options to Combat Challenges
The paper also provides a range of potential solutions that may improve the long-term viability of exchanges. They include:
The report concluded: “A combination of these and other policies may need to be considered by the executive branch, Congress, or states to ensure market stability into the future.”
New Research Challenges Assumptions About Hospital-Physician Integration, Medicare Patient Mix
April 22nd 2025On this episode of Managed Care Cast, Brady Post, PhD, lead author of a study published in the April 2025 issue of The American Journal of Managed Care®, challenges the claim that hospital-employed physicians serve a more complex patient mix.
Listen
Integrated CKD Care Model Cuts ED Visits by 30%, Boosts Specialized Treatment
April 21st 2025An analysis of an interdisciplinary care model for managing chronic kidney disease (CKD) shows hospital admissions dropped by 26% and emergency department (ED) visits decreased by 30% after clinic initiation.
Read More
Personalized Care Key as Tirzepatide Use Expands Rapidly
April 15th 2025Using commercial insurance claims data and the US launch of tirzepatide as their dividing point, John Ostrominski, MD, Harvard Medical School, and his team studied trends in the use of both glucose-lowering and weight-lowering medications, comparing outcomes between adults with and without type 2 diabetes.
Listen
No Major Shifts in OBGYN Practice Locations Found Post Dobbs Decision
April 21st 2025Despite widespread concern following the Dobbs v Jackson Women’s Health Organization decision, researchers found no significant changes nationwide in obstetrician and gynecologist (OBGYN) practice locations.
Read More